full

Why Your Popup Only Gets 8%: The 15% Opt-In Playbook | Shaan Arora, Alia

Published on: 5th June, 2026

Your popup probably converts at 8%. The best Shopify brands are pulling 15 to 20% with the same traffic, and this episode is the playbook.

In this episode of Ecom Growth Insider, Shaan Arora, co-founder and CEO of Alia, breaks down the popup playbook he built into Shopify's fastest-growing popup app. Alia now powers Nike Strength, Peloton, Hot Ones, HexClad, ILIA Beauty, Milk Makeup, Skims, Toms, Aviator Nation, and 3,000+ other Shopify brands.

Shaan and his co-founders Cory Gill and Bill Wohlers bootstrapped Alia from $1M to $8M ARR in one year, then sold to Dotdigital in March 2026 for a $60M exit. No outside funding. No debt. Profitable since day one.

Shaan's popup testing priority:

Test timing first (5 seconds is the default).

Test copy second (mystery discount versus standard percent off).

Test X-button placement and exit delay.

Track on-site CVR alongside opt-in rate.

In this episode:

- Why Klaviyo's 1 to 5% "healthy" opt-in benchmark is wrong (Alia's brands hit 10 to 15%, sometimes 20%+)

- The single biggest lift on opt-in rate: copy, not design

- When mystery discounts beat standard percent-off offers (and the brand sizes where each wins)

- Why gamified popups (Plinko, slots, spin-to-win) work for some brands and kill the experience for others

- How Aviator Nation doubled their welcome flow revenue by fixing their popup

- The on-site CVR metric most popup tools don't track (and why it matters more than opt-in rate)

- How Alia captures quiz data even when a visitor doesn't submit their email

- The default 5-second trigger plus the "smart trigger" that re-shows the popup on the second pageview

- How to segment new vs returning visitors without giving away your margin twice

- The popup program differences between $1M, $10M, and $100M brands

- What Alia did differently to attract the Dotdigital acquisition

- Why Shaan would take 30% of $60M over 100% of $1M every time

Chapters:

00:00 Why most founders miss the popup growth lever

01:09 The invisible cost of a bad popup

02:15 Healthy opt-in benchmarks: Klaviyo's 1 to 5% vs Alia's 10 to 15%

04:11 What Alia's smart testing actually tests

05:05 The single biggest lift on conversion: copy

10:17 Gamified popups that convert: Plinko, slots, characters

13:05 The on-site CVR metric most popup tools ignore

14:24 Aviator Nation: how a popup fix doubled welcome flow revenue

16:47 Default timing setup and the smart-trigger second showing

19:14 New vs returning visitor segmentation

20:26 What every top popup program has in common

24:26 If you could only test one thing

25:24 Differences between $1M, $10M, and $100M brand popup programs

28:35 Building polished popups for premium brands (and when to skip the discount)

30:52 The Dotdigital acquisition: how it happened

32:56 Bootstrapped to $8M ARR in one year: what Alia did differently

34:15 The one thing Shaan would do again (and why co-founders matter)

37:19 Why sales is the best founder education

39:02 Where to find Shaan

Connect with Shaan:

Alia (book a demo): https://aliapopups.com

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/shaan-arora/

X: https://x.com/iamshaanarora

Ecom Growth Insider is the podcast for e-commerce founders who want to scale profitably. New episodes weekly on paid media, CRO, offer strategy, and operating systems that actually move the needle.

More episodes and newsletter: https://ecomgrowthinsider.com

Work with HoloGrowth: https://hologrowth.com

All Episodes Previous Episode

Listen for free

Show artwork for Ecom Growth Insider

About the Podcast

Ecom Growth Insider
Real behind-the-scenes strategies from the trenches of scaling DTC brands. With founders, marketers, and growth experts.
If you're a DTC brand founder, CMO, growth marketer, or operator trying to scale your e-commerce business profitably, this podcast is for you.

Hosted by Andrej Tumachowitsch — founder of the growth agency HoloGrowth — this show goes deep on what actually works to grow online brands in today’s ultra-competitive landscape.

We go way beyond generic advice.

Every episode gives you practical, battle-tested insights directly from 7-, 8-, and 9-figure brand founders, top-tier marketers, and agency operators actively working in the trenches.

You’ll learn:
- What separates breakout ecom brands from the ones that plateau
- Paid media strategies that scale on Meta, Google & beyond
- How to use UGC, email, landing pages, and CRO to increase LTV & AOV
- Creative testing frameworks & campaign breakdowns that actually perform
- Smart ways to grow without sacrificing profit margins
- Founder mindsets, systems, and hiring practices that lead to longevity
- And the biggest mistakes brands are making right now (and how to avoid them)

Expect a mix of founder interviews, expert roundtables, solo lessons, and deep dives into what’s working right now in paid acquisition, conversion, and retention.

No fluff. No recycled advice. Just proven strategies to grow your ecommerce brand.

If you're tired of surface-level podcasts and want unfiltered access to the tactics and lessons real brands are using to scale — hit subscribe and join us inside the Ecom Growth Insider.

About your host

Profile picture for Andrej Tumachowitsch

Andrej Tumachowitsch

I'm the founder of HoloGrowth, a performance-driven growth agency helping e-commerce brands scale profitably to 7- and 8-figures through paid ads.

With years of experience in the trenches of DTC growth, I have worked with over 30 brands worldwide – building, optimizing, and scaling their marketing systems.

As the host of the Ecom Growth Insider podcast, I dive deep with top founders, marketers, and growth experts to unpack what’s really working behind the scenes in the DTC space.

My mission? To bring raw, actionable insights that help brand owners scale smarter.